Reflections on maths, learning and maths learning support, by David K Butler

Tag: psychology

  • Numbers or Letters

    After 13 years of playing Numbers and Letters at open days and orientations, I have noticed something interesting, but not really surprising, and also a bit sad.

    We set up the Numbers Game and the Letters Game next to each other, either on the same whiteboard

    A whiteboard with some laminated instructions on it, as well as a lot of writing in marker. One title is "Letters Game". Under that is "List of Letters" which has below it nine letters written. The writing is all words using the letters. Another title is "Numbers Game". Under that is "List of Numbers" which has below it six numbers written. Under that is "Target Numbers", which below it has a five by three grid of 15 consecutive three digit numbers. The writing is all calculations using the numbers equal to the targets.

    or on two whiteboards

    Then students and community members join in with the games, which affords us an opportunity to talk with them about the support that’s available at Adelaide University.

    The thing I’ve noticed is that people almost always choose just one of the games to play. Some of them do it quietly without a fuss, while others loudly express distain for or distress at the other game.

    I don’t mind at all people choosing to play just one of the games as they feel inspired today. That’s one of the reasons we have two games. What bothers me is that a large number of people really do believe that you can be either a numbers person or a letters person, but definitely can’t be both. What bothers me more is that some people seem to think that one of those types of person is a more worthy person to be.

    I’m not surprised that people feel this way. We as a society spend a lot of time telling people that they are or are not maths people, and that they are or are not writing people, and directing them away from those activities whenever they struggle with them. We also tell them that they can be only one type of person, that being a maths person is antithetical to being a word person, that being interested in or good at more than one thing is showing off.

    It makes me sad when I see evidence of these lies every time I play Numbers and Letters. I weep because the lies are so pervasive that they even prevent people from playing a little collaborative game with no consequences.

    But I’ll keep at it. Because I would dearly love to live in a world where ordinary everyday people were allowed to play both Numbers and Letters.

  • Australia’s Got Dedication

    In the MLC Drop-In Centre, it sometimes happens that students succeed quite well at their maths, and yet somehow they manage to actually feel bad about it. They say that they only succeeded because they worked hard, and not because they are “good at maths”, implying that somehow natural talent is more worthy of praise. Well I’m here to say this is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard.

    If you did well at maths because of your hard work, then you should feel proud! You should feel proud because that outcome is the result of your own personal effort – you were the one personally responsible for your own success.

    On the other hand, if you were born with a natural talent for learning maths concepts, if you always found it easy to solve maths problems and if you don’t have to work to get high grades in maths, then the best you can feel is lucky. If you really were born with a talent, then none of that success is really your fault at all, and you have no right to feel proud about it. You might as well feel proud of the colour of your eyes.

    Even in the TV show “Australia’s Got Talent”, if you listen closely you’ll find that the finalists are not there because of their so-called talent. No, the judges are giving them praise because of their bravery and hard work and in fact they deal out criticism for simply riding on raw talent. In short, perhaps a more accurate title for the show would be “Australia’s Got Dedication.”

    So start giving yourself some credit and stop beating yourself up for not being “naturally good at” maths! You’ve got something you can legitimately feel proud of – you’ve got dedication!


    These comments were left on the original blog post:

    David Butler 5 November 2013:
    Oh and PS: The concept that some people are “good at maths” or “not good at maths” is a myth anyway: http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2013/10/the-myth-of-im-bad… 

    Trang Nguyen 5 November 2013:
    http://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/does-one-have-to-be-a-geniu… 

  • Beware of the Toast

    There is a little trick someone played on me once as a child and I have been playing on the students in the Drop-In room this week. It goes like this:

    Answer the following questions:

    • What would you find in a haunted house?
    • What do you call a meal of meat cooked in an oven?
    • What is the part of the country that is next to the sea?
    • When you have more than everyone else, what would you have?
    • What do you put in a toaster?

    The answers to these questions are of course, a ghost, a roast, the coast, the most and… bread. You weren’t thinking toast were you? 😉

    You may ask why I’m playing such a mean trick on my students, when normally I am adamant that we shouldn’t make our students feel stupid. Fair point, but I think it will help them feel less stupid in the end.

    You see it all started when one of the students was doing “volume of revolution” problems. Every problem so far had required him to take a 2D shape and rotate it around the x-axis, thus creating a solid 3D shape. The next problem, however, required him to rotate around a different line outside the 2D shape, thus creating a 3D shape with a hole in it. It said on the page it had to be rotated around a different line, and yet he still rotated around the x-axis anyway. “Why did I do that?” he asked. And in response I played the above trick.

    The point is that humans are good at following patterns, so good that we don’t even know we’re doing it. In general this is actually a good thing – it means you can set a table, sing music, do jigsaw puzzles, count, learn languages and and even learn maths. But sometimes it fails us, because things don’t always fit into a pattern. Just because the first four answers rhyme with GHOST, it doesn’t mean they all will; just because all questions so far require rotating around the x-axis, it doesn’t mean they all will.

    So for students, the message is to keep your mind open. Don’t just follow the pattern, but think carefully about what the problem at hand requires you to do. For teachers, we should be careful to put in more than one type of example, so that students aren’t encouraged to form a pattern that isn’t there. In short, for all of us: Beware of the toast.